Skip to content
Anabaptist Perspectives
All essays
essay

How Can “Anabaptism” Fulfill Its Destiny to Become Just Plain “Christianity”?

Reed Merino

How Can “Anabaptism” Fulfill Its Destiny to Become Just Plain “Christianity”?

Soon to be 85, I have had a passion for over 65 years to see passionate Christians restore the unity that characterized Christ’s apostolically founded churches in our initial centuries. Thanks perhaps to the influence of the Confessions of Augustine of Hippo, that passion began on the very day that his own decisions had inspired me to surrender my life to Jesus while I was a young Merchant Marine Academy cadet on a voyage to South Africa in 1960. In my subsequent years as a “critical scholar” Episcopal priest, that passion led me to the ecumenical “Consultation on Church Union” movement. However, in 1972, after being restored to the Biblical simplicity with which I had first come to Christ, I abandoned those kinds of “ecumenical” attempts because of the awareness that the churches which I had known, some of which were involved in that “ecumenical movement,” would still be as spiritually dead AFTER such unification as most of them had been PRIOR to it.

That “ecumenical” passion has persisted, but in a new form, now based upon drawing together those who actually feel the need to be surrendered in childlike trust to both the spirit and the letter of everything that Jesus and His Apostles have taught, based upon the principle that what has been taught, promised, and commanded by them virtually always simply means some grammatically natural and literal sense of what it seems to mean. That “exegetical method” is actually the instinct that all of us already use when reading serious historical, biographical or scientific literature—a good communicator carefully chooses the best words that will be understandable to all of those in his audience. And since the vast majority of Jesus’s original audience were fishermen, farmers, carpenters and housewives, He and His Spirit-anointed apostles, made sure to communicate in the way that they were used to thinking and speaking. And those “normal” people instinctively assumed that He simply meant precisely what His words usually meant. Jesus did use parables and some cryptic statements (e.g., “Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.”)—but that was not the case when He and His apostles gave His specific doctrines, promises, and commands! I first discovered that surprisingly simple “exegetical method” by extensive reading of the writings of the pre-Constantinian church’s leaders. I was wonderfully surprised to discover that if you read the doctrines, promises, and commands of Jesus and His apostles, and then took them in that grammatically natural and literal sense, you discovered that you virtually always wound up with the official teachings of those ancient Christians!

I later discovered when studying the history of the Reformation that it was you Anabaptists who were the restorers of that simple exegetical instinct in the 16th century! Other Reformation leaders did take specific New Testament passages in that literal way – here and there – but your founders seemed to have inhaled it as a foundational instinct dealing with the most costly and revolutionary passages, passages dealing with how a Christian is to behave! And rather than using the normal Protestant and Catholic violence to defend their cause, they were willing to pay the cost of their conviction by embracing the suffering that Christ told them to expect. In doing so, they also restored the ancient Church of the holy martyrs!

To use an example of that “grammatically natural and literal” instinct that you Anabaptists restored and all know so well, “Do NOT resist him who is evil” meant to them what it seems to be saying, after you examine the way that Jesus and His apostles and the ancient Christians specifically modeled that teaching. He was free and bold enough to call some hypocritical leaders “whitened sepulchers,” but He (and His subsequent apostles and churches) never resorted to physical violence! That “it means what it says” idea is the exegetical principle that your own founders used on the rest of that Sermon on the Mount, and which got them into so much trouble. Yet that instinct was also one of whose “basics” which established an idea that has greatly influenced the founders of the American Republic: the separation of church and state. That was YOUR unique idea, an idea that seemingly no one else even thought to “restore” as essential to apostolic Christianity!

For some years, I have been involved in several media platforms—Facebook.com and MeWe.com. Most of those groups deal with Biblical and theological discussions. The participants in these groups come from all manner of backgrounds: Evangelical Protestant, Fundamentalist, Mainline Protestant, Anglican, Pentecostal, Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox. 

But, the group whose typical absence both surprises and distresses me, is yours!  Your founders’ bold and costly embrace of Jesus’s Sermon on the Mount shocked and frightened the leaders of the Protestant Reformation groups and the Roman Catholic Counter-Reformation. This embrace of the Sermon on the Mount had dangerous consequences for their different, but highly compromised, varieties of Constantinian Christianity. Back then, you Anabaptists were aggressively engaged in dialogue, debate, and writings, in order to get them to see the missing “elephant in the living room” in all of their versions of “essential Christianity:” no matter how wonderful theological constructs might be, unless you are surrendered to both the letter and the spirit of those costly discipleship teachings and commands of Jesus then you have not yet entered His Kingdom of God!

That is what inspired your forefathers to restore the ancient “church of martyrs” to earth! Most Reformation era “martyrs” were people who either died in battle defending their causes, like Zwingli, or who had been executed for supported the wrong side in some state-church battle over “reform.” But your ancestors had a pure form of martyrdom. They were executed for having the dangerous conviction that would have overthrown ANY version of state sponsored church. That is why you eventually became my Reformation “heroes” sometime after I first read about you in my college European history days.

What distresses me about you all in our day is that I cannot remember ever hearing any of you Anabaptists in these social media discussion groups. I, who am no longer a member of your denominations, openly speak out defending your cause among them far, far more than YOU do! You should be as engaged with them as your bloodied original leaders were, because what they had to say is still every bit as important and challenging today as it had been back then!

It is true that most Americans in these groups do not support any form of the old world’s “Christian state church” ideologies because America’s founders renounced any such form of “alliance” from its foundation—an idea that YOU had first restored to the earth! However, many, if not most, still think one can engage in the institutional violence of this world and yet claim to be in the Kingdom of God because of being “born again” or having “accepted Christ as Lord and Savior,” or they think violence can be justified because this American nation is not a member of that “world” that Jesus described, since it is supposedly founded upon “Judeo-Christian values”! Many or most of those American Christians have developed dangerous political and psychological loyalties to the currently warring political groups within the country. Their churches are more culturally “American” than the separated and tightly knit functional communities raised up by Christ’s holy apostles—that “holy nation” and “special people” of God defined by Peter.

Although your dress codes have evolved into styles that often make you more “quaint” than your own ancestors had adopted, many or most of the social media participants belong to denominations and traditions that do not even have a theoretical vision for embracing the simple and humble lifestyles that you have embraced. The “prosperity gospel” does not blend well with martyrdom! Over the past decades, most of the individuals that I have met who are passionate about discovering or restoring apostolic Christianity first looked to YOUR history as their inspiration and model. But many, including me in the ten years I was a member, were saddened to see the difference between that first passion and its current comparatively tamed condition.

Virtually all of our post-Constantinian versions of Christianity need to be further purged and reformed by the Spirit of Jesus that was manifested within His inspired new covenant writings. But one of the ways for that to bear fruit requires that we engage in serious and challenging dialogues that will enable us to recognize the undigestible “bones” in our own group and the Biblical “meat” that is within some of the others. If you all were much more willing to engage in that dialogue, both you and they would be blessed! 

My understanding, perhaps flawed, is that the Anabaptists were so harshly persecuted by their supposedly Christian opponents who lived in their supposedly Christian nations that they became willing to become the silent in the land who “keep themselves to themselves” in the hopes that they will somehow be eventually “discovered” by those who seek them out: an attitude far removed from the apostolic churches! That mentality is something about which to be ashamed or embarrassed, not contented or justified. Our Master gave a command to “Go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.” In the decade in which I was a member of Towamencin Mennonite Church in Lansdale PA, and in the decades since then, I discovered that Anabaptists tend to be far more willing to support the evangelization of another continent than they are to evangelize their own towns or engage in challenging Christendom’s many worldly churches in the way that your bold founders did.

They really need to hear from you, and be both challenged and perhaps disturbed by you, whether by personal contact or by the wonders of social media. They need to be disturbed by your original message! And you will be blessed (as well as disturbed) by hearing back from them. God has been at work among some of them in a way that would complete the vision that your bold founders started among you!

And you really do need to listen to some of those other movements. The so-called “ANAbaptists” – who never RE-baptized anyone! – started out as a movement that sought to restore the same version of “My Church” that Jesus had brought to the earth. That movement was based upon the simple instinct that Jesus and His Spirit-inspired apostles really knew how to “say what He meant, and that He meant what He said!” So, when they read that He commissioned them to “… make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit …” (Matthew 28:18), the simple and obvious conclusion is that you first make what JESUS would accept as a “disciple” and THEN you baptize them. So simple, so obvious, but so neglected even in our day! And then, when they read where He called Satan “the ruler of this world” (John 12:31, 14:30, 16:11) and Paul called him the “god of this world” (2 Corinthians 4:4), it only made sense to them that any empire or nation that CLAIMED to be “Christian,” but is filled by supposed “Christians” who are not actual disciples of Jesus, is in truth merely a religious form of “this world” and therefore cannot and must not be accepted as some form of “covenant partners.” These simple disciples of Jesus actually restored as a sort of “exegetical method” the principle that when reading the literature of the New Covenant one must assume that its doctrines, commands, and promises actually mean some serious and literal form of what they SEEM to be saying.

But what began as a Spirit-inspired “movement” has sadly become one more of the many Christian “denominations.” A “movement” brings a godly exegetical principle into being and then believes, obeys, and experiences it consistently throughout ANY and ALL of the Spirit-inspired writings that it encounters, until what is described within the New Testament about “My church” finally is a description of themselves! What the Spirit of Jesus raised up and caused to be described was intended to be both possible and an actual description of His holy people throughout the rest of human history, not a description of some “fairy tale” kingdom that only existed “once upon a time, in a land far, far away!” Your movement gradually became content to freeze and memorialize the achievements of your first generation of spiritual pioneers into the several Anabaptist denominations that were produced back then, instead of continuing to discover and build upon the interpretive instinct that they had recovered.

Why, for example, did you not eagerly rediscover that the Jesus who meant what He said regarding “baptize THEM” also meant a grammatically natural and literal version of what he said when saying, “These signs WILL follow those who believe…”? (Mark 16:17-18).

Or, why would you not interpret what happens within the Lord’s Supper according to some grammatically natural and literal version of what He actually said, when He said, “This IS my body… blood” (Matthew 26:26) and when Paul said, “The BREAD that we break, is IT not the communion [“koinonia”] of the body of Christ…” (1 Corinthians 10:16). The ancient churches’ leaders always understood that what they were receiving in the “Lord’s Supper” or “Eucharist” was some real version of “the body and blood” of the risen and glorified Jesus, even though they did not feel the need to define it with some precise formulation like the medieval Roman church’s “transubstantiation.” Why did I have to learn that ancient church’s understanding from a godly Episcopal priest back in the 1960’s rather than from you all? And, much more important than merely changing my intellectual understanding about what I was receiving in that Supper, was that because I did accept that more literal “doctrine,” I eventually began to personally recognize and experience the “Who” that was underlying that doctrine: with my eyes of faith I am now able to believe, sense, and even “feel” that He is quite literally present in that Eucharistic assembly in His invisible glory, and that He is quite literally fulfilling one of His wonderful promises: “Christ IN you, the hope of glory!”

That “eucharistic instinct” of the ancient churches was not focused upon Jesus as He was at the time of that “last supper,” but upon the Jesus described by Paul:

“It is ‘planted’ a natural body, and it is raised a spiritual body. There is a natural body and there is a spiritual body.So also it is written: ‘The first man, Adam, became a living being;’ the last Adam became a life-giving spirit” (1 Corinthians 15:44-45). Just as you already know that Jesus was more literal than most Christians accept about “disciple’s baptism,” why do you not realize that He was equally literal when He said, “This IS my body … blood”? As always, His words mean what they seem to be saying!

Furthermore, why would you not interpret according to some grammatically natural and literal version of what He and Paul said about the “celibate life” as being clearly recommended:

“His disciples said to Him, ‘If such is the case of the man with his wife, it is better not to marry.’ But He said to them, ‘All cannot accept this saying, but only those to whom it has been given:For there are eunuchs who were born thus from their mother’s womb, and there are eunuchs who were made eunuchs by men, and there are eunuchs who have made themselves eunuchs for the kingdom of heaven’s sake. He who is able to accept it LET him accept it” (Matthew 19:10-12).

Paul’s teaching is as Spirit-inspired as any other teaching you had restored: “For I wish that all men were even as I myself. But each one has his own gift from God, one in this manner and another in that. But I say to the unmarried and to the widows: It is good for them if they remain even as I am” (1 Corinthians 7:7-8).

“He who is unmarried cares for the things of the Lord–how he may please the Lord. But he who is married cares about the things of the world–how he may please his wife. There is a difference between a wife and a virgin. The unmarried woman cares about the things of the Lord, that she may be holy both in body and in spirit. But she who is married cares about the things of the world–how she may please [her] husband.”… So then he who gives her in marriage does WELL, but he who does not give her in marriage does BETTER” (1 Corinthians 7:32…38).

While it is clear that such celibacy is not at all required, it is equally clear that both Jesus, Paul, AND the ancient churches did believe that such celibacy was indeed “given” by God to some, and that such a calling was a “better” way of life. Are not such portions of Scripture as equally Spirit-inspired as the others? Why have you not institutionalized such a “better” calling as celibacy within your tradition? In the apostolically founded churches, the vowed celibates became some of the most bold and death-defying missionaries! Anyone who loves the Word of God ought to love those relevant passages, and seriously ask God whether he or she “has been “given” that calling by God, no?

And the issues that I have mentioned above are but a few examples of what is yet to be restored in order to make your movement truly apostolic, no? A careful reading of the New Testament cannot help but reveal that Jesus was just as thoughtful in creating all the needed callings, ministries, and institutions of His “holy nation, His own special people” as He was when creating His nation of Israel, and when He designed and created the first human body with all of its trillions of needed cells, organs and structures! My own attempts to discover those “components” produced two volumes of almost seven hundred pages! They are embarrassingly clear to those who are determined to find them and act upon them!

The restoration movement that your founders began is still in GREAT need of being reinvigorated and brought back to life. God has moved on other groups that came after to you to see things in His Word that needed to be restored—restored upon that wonderful exegetical principle that “What it means is what it SEEMS to mean!” My personal assumption is that the only reason that He used other groups of later eager followers rather than continuing to use you is because He could no longer use YOU – because you were content to have frozen into a denomination what He had started among your founders as His holy movement!

I sincerely hope that this is not taken as an offense. I learned so much from your founders that has deeply reoriented my life—but I also learned much that is also Biblical from some of those other movements!  Yet, over the decades I have come to the conclusion that in the coming together of sincere followers of Jesus it is only those [mistakenly] called “Anabaptists” who can provide the “foundation on the rock” (Luke 6:48), upon which His restored and unified house can be built. That is because it is only your movement upon which He had established the most important, most costly, and most elementary teachings of Jesus: how to become a true disciple of Jeus by paying careful attention to such specific commands as are found in teachings such as His “Sermon on the Mount” of Matthew 5-7! For the rest of Christendom’s versions of Christianity those teachings have become vague ideals, which do not get in the way of allowing their members to live in what they believe is the “real world.” Your movement was the only one that properly elevated them as His version of “canon law” that determines whether – in fact – you have become a Christian at all! For them, if you are not committed to embrace that Sermon on the Mount then you are not yet a Christian, no matter what other portions of His teachings you may embrace So simple! And so dangerous!

When Jesus drew me back to a commitment to be unconditionally and uncompromisingly loyal to Him in 1972, I started to reexperience HIS passion for us to break out of our denominational shells for HIS sake. And He still has that passion. I can find no deeper passion than what He prayed to His Father in John 17 immediately before His suffering:

“I am not praying only on their behalf, but also on behalf of those who believe in me through their testimony” [that is US] ” that they will all BE one, just as you, Father, are in me and I am in you. I pray that they will be in us, so that the world will believe that you sent me.” [which necessarily also means that our fractured disunity helps the world to NOT believe!] The glory you gave to me I have given to them, that they may be one just as we are one—I in them and you in me—that they may be completely one, so that the WORLD will know that you sent me, and you have loved them just as you have loved me” [Their original unity that transcends national and cultural borders DID have that amazing effect among those whom God was calling!]

And what if it turns out that this prayed passion of His is so serious to Him that our judgment will include how passionate we have been to fulfill what He had prayed there‽

View original publication

Keep exploring.