Why We Publish Disagreements and Divergent Experiences

We respond to a pointed listener rebuke of one of our testimony episodes. What should we do when someone tells their story in ways we doubt or disagree with? Are testimonies meant to be evaluated for precision and balance, or received as accounts of lived experience? We discuss concerns about truthfulness and contradiction, and engage with the question of how Christians can listen when stories are shaped more by experience than by argument.

This conversation is part of the partner library.